Testing cycle-freeness: Finding a certificate

We deal with the problem of designing one-sided error property testers for cycle-freeness in bounded degree graphs. Such a property tester always accepts forests. Furthermore, when it rejects an input, it provides a short cycle as a certificate. The problem of testing cycle-freeness in this model was first considered by Goldreich and Ron [13]. They give a constant time tester with two-sided error (it does not provide certificates for rejection) and prove a Ω( √ n) lower bound for testers with one-sided error. We design a property tester with one-sided error whose running time matches this lower bound (upto polylogarithmic factors). Interestingly, this has connections to a recent conjecture of Benjamini, Schramm, and Shapira [3]. The property of cycle-freeness is closed under the operation of taking minors. This is the first example of such a property that has an almost optimal Õ( √ n)-time one-sided error tester, but has a constant time two-sided error tester. It was conjectured in [3] that this happens for a vast class of minor-closed properties, and this result can seen as the first indication towards that.